The title of the blog seems to be very strange and if you are wondering what I am up to this time then don’t worry "your ideas would get clear here on".
I was just relaxing and watching “The BUCK STOPS HERE” a talk or debate show hosted by Barkha Dutt a senior journalists. The topic was Ajmal Kasab court trial. There were lot of distinguish personalities who were throwing a lot of ideas and thoughts, interpretations, conclusions and Barkha was catching everything and collating them together for the viewer to analyze and ponder on it.
Some basic jargons, if I dare say to that language, which was spoken in the show, was terrorists, fundamentalists, Islamists, communalists, fascist, racist, extremist etc. As I was hearing them speak and most of the related shows on even other issues in India we often hear similar verbose to the one above. The point I am making here takes us to the title of the blog, rather makes half of the title i.e. THE “ISTS” part of it.
What I wanted the distinguished guests to tackle or speak about is THE “ISMS” behind every such “ISTS” i.e. for example when we speak about terrorists then what about Terror”ism”. If we are speaking about Extremists then why don’t we speak about Extremism and so on………
From what as a English language student I understand is a Terrorists or any “…ISTS” is completely dependent on the “…..ISM” that motivates and propels the individual to become an “IST” of that nature.
The very notion above is good enough, to make us realize what we have to do in order to achieve what we wish to. For example we want to end Terror then finishing terrorists is not going to solve the problem. We have to work towards solving TERRORISM. If the “ISM” ends then the motivations that propels people to kill so many also is killed. The base on which this game is played is no more the motivation.
If I look at myself and see what today can propel me to be a part of a plan to kill so many innocent people, it would need immensely high level of motivational talk aided with proofs, images, statistics, fundamentals which would then create a high amount of emotional turbulence in me and I would want to take revenge by whatever means being made available to me. Basically I want to revenge whether if it’s the right way or wrong its immaterial for me. Such a high motivation is generated in people like Kasab which is very dangerous. The basic point is there are some people who has something with them which can create Kasabs. This again boomerangs a question onto us that have we done something wrong which is being used against us. Is the onus on us here rather than them???
I mean there could be more than what we see here. The motivational facts would be false but not entirely. There would be some strong reasoning which we are overlooking and/or missing something to this whole issue of Terrorists and their Terrorism. We have over these years, failed to understand their problem or the motivation that they provide to people like Kasab to go and create such carnage.
Here I am not justifying what Kasab did but I am saying there is more to it than mere act that he has performed. By hanging him, we can only revenge what he did but I think that neither makes our lives secure nor guarantee that there would be no more of such attack.
Did our government, we as people tried implementing, learnt from what inspired him to kill so many hapless people. Forget that did we try to understand the “ISM” behind the “ISTS” in Kasab. There could some starch realities, some mistakes we would have done that has reaped us the crop called Kasab. Are we even contemplating such a thing?
If we assume that Kasab was motivated from outside India and we as a nation can’t do much about it then what about the Maosits, Naxals or BODO. They are the locals and not someones who came from outside. Did we ever try to de-alienate the local people from the insurgent groups? Where are these groups of terror getting recruits from? They have a steady flow of recruits, which is a proof that they have something to tell and motivate people to join them. They can’t sustain by making people join them by force for such a long time. This motivation given to people is the root of the “ISMS” that has created the “ISTS”.
Any ill “ISMS” should be tackled and the problems have to be nipped in the bud, neutralize the motivations that make up the “ISMS” whether its Terrorism, Pessimisms, casteism, Racism etc….. we try to change individual and make him, bring him on other side of the “IST” spectrum but fail because the “ISMS” remain in the background and the change is therefore superficial.
The danger lies in the “ISMS” that we knowingly/unknowingly create due to our vested interests and not the “ISTS” that come up later. The “ISTS” are only the immediate consequences of the “ISMS” and they don’t die till the time “ISMS” exists. We can only prevent and feel lucky that we did not fall prey to the Consequence like Kasab this time but this does not guarantee any future setbacks to us.
I was just relaxing and watching “The BUCK STOPS HERE” a talk or debate show hosted by Barkha Dutt a senior journalists. The topic was Ajmal Kasab court trial. There were lot of distinguish personalities who were throwing a lot of ideas and thoughts, interpretations, conclusions and Barkha was catching everything and collating them together for the viewer to analyze and ponder on it.
Some basic jargons, if I dare say to that language, which was spoken in the show, was terrorists, fundamentalists, Islamists, communalists, fascist, racist, extremist etc. As I was hearing them speak and most of the related shows on even other issues in India we often hear similar verbose to the one above. The point I am making here takes us to the title of the blog, rather makes half of the title i.e. THE “ISTS” part of it.
What I wanted the distinguished guests to tackle or speak about is THE “ISMS” behind every such “ISTS” i.e. for example when we speak about terrorists then what about Terror”ism”. If we are speaking about Extremists then why don’t we speak about Extremism and so on………
From what as a English language student I understand is a Terrorists or any “…ISTS” is completely dependent on the “…..ISM” that motivates and propels the individual to become an “IST” of that nature.
The very notion above is good enough, to make us realize what we have to do in order to achieve what we wish to. For example we want to end Terror then finishing terrorists is not going to solve the problem. We have to work towards solving TERRORISM. If the “ISM” ends then the motivations that propels people to kill so many also is killed. The base on which this game is played is no more the motivation.
If I look at myself and see what today can propel me to be a part of a plan to kill so many innocent people, it would need immensely high level of motivational talk aided with proofs, images, statistics, fundamentals which would then create a high amount of emotional turbulence in me and I would want to take revenge by whatever means being made available to me. Basically I want to revenge whether if it’s the right way or wrong its immaterial for me. Such a high motivation is generated in people like Kasab which is very dangerous. The basic point is there are some people who has something with them which can create Kasabs. This again boomerangs a question onto us that have we done something wrong which is being used against us. Is the onus on us here rather than them???
I mean there could be more than what we see here. The motivational facts would be false but not entirely. There would be some strong reasoning which we are overlooking and/or missing something to this whole issue of Terrorists and their Terrorism. We have over these years, failed to understand their problem or the motivation that they provide to people like Kasab to go and create such carnage.
Here I am not justifying what Kasab did but I am saying there is more to it than mere act that he has performed. By hanging him, we can only revenge what he did but I think that neither makes our lives secure nor guarantee that there would be no more of such attack.
Did our government, we as people tried implementing, learnt from what inspired him to kill so many hapless people. Forget that did we try to understand the “ISM” behind the “ISTS” in Kasab. There could some starch realities, some mistakes we would have done that has reaped us the crop called Kasab. Are we even contemplating such a thing?
If we assume that Kasab was motivated from outside India and we as a nation can’t do much about it then what about the Maosits, Naxals or BODO. They are the locals and not someones who came from outside. Did we ever try to de-alienate the local people from the insurgent groups? Where are these groups of terror getting recruits from? They have a steady flow of recruits, which is a proof that they have something to tell and motivate people to join them. They can’t sustain by making people join them by force for such a long time. This motivation given to people is the root of the “ISMS” that has created the “ISTS”.
Any ill “ISMS” should be tackled and the problems have to be nipped in the bud, neutralize the motivations that make up the “ISMS” whether its Terrorism, Pessimisms, casteism, Racism etc….. we try to change individual and make him, bring him on other side of the “IST” spectrum but fail because the “ISMS” remain in the background and the change is therefore superficial.
The danger lies in the “ISMS” that we knowingly/unknowingly create due to our vested interests and not the “ISTS” that come up later. The “ISTS” are only the immediate consequences of the “ISMS” and they don’t die till the time “ISMS” exists. We can only prevent and feel lucky that we did not fall prey to the Consequence like Kasab this time but this does not guarantee any future setbacks to us.
5 comments:
Very true Ashish....u nailed it.....but then again there is a bigger picture to the whole problem......i personally feel extremism is one of the causes of terrorism......pardon my limited knowledge of the local terror groups....
Very well written............
Very impressive work Ashish... Few comments.
One important motivating factor for terror-ISM by people like Kasab is their financial conditions. Sometimes such people come from very poor families, and the guarantee that their families will be well taken care of could be an important driving factor for such terror-ISM..
You mentioned in your blog that " If the “ISM” ends then the motivations that propels people to kill so many also is killed "..What do you think could be the root cause of the ISM that drives crazy people like Kasab?
If you have a look at India's history and of the whole world, you might see that majority of the infamous wars and battles happened on the basis of - Religion !!
I was watching a documentary on BBC the other day.. It was about the life of Devadassi(es) in India. You might know that these women( as young as 8-9 year olds) are thrown in Sex-trade in the name of Goddess Yellaamma by their very own family members. Majority of them are HIV+ and have given birth to kids at a tender age of 15-16, who are also HIV+. Some of them have even committed suicide or have died early of various diseases. this is just one..
Why I give you this example is because you mentioned about Kasab and his Terror-ISM..
Religious extremISM branches into or has many Classifications.. Terro-ISM is just one, Devadassi-ISM for instance is another horrendous example and there are many more. Do you think it enough to just get rid of one classification without tackling the root cause?
Bitter as it might be, but there are KASABS in many many of our own households, and these Kasabs are a prey to one or more of such fanatic classifications.
Should someone really feel 'lucky' for not having been caught in the infamous war of Terror-ISM led by Kasab and his small gang on 26th Nov?? Then what about the sick, rudimentary and ill-practices in Religious-ISM of which we are already Slaves since Centuries...
Most of us are lucky enough to escape Terror-ISM but 'NONE' of us can escape the root cause of Terrorism that is -- "Religious ExtremISM"..
Sheetal.Shirsat-Rohekar
Ashish -- The TerrorIST(S) are not robbed of money/richness etc.etc.. In fact they and their future generations are paid a grand amount to conduct such acts of Terrorism..
Now you say that even if I was robbed of my richness/wealth etc.,I wouldn't conduct a cruel act of killing people. Why, because I am educated and have knowledge. Certainly, I would not do such things, even if someone robbed me.
BUT.. BUT..let me give you the flip side and put it to you this way (and by the way this is a personal fact). Last summer I visited the Imperial War Museum in London. This museum is built after 2nd world war, and hosts all pictures, photos, video clips of the Holocaust which was led by Adolf Hitler and his Nazi Army..It also has got personal interviews of people who escaped the holocaust but lost some of their relatives in it.. I hope you know what Holocaust was.. If not, I will briefly tell you about it. In the Holocaust movement, Hitler and his armies brutally killed Jews. Men and women, children were separately taken into chambers where they had to inhale poisonous gases. once they died, their bodies were thrown in pits.. Thousands of innocent jews were killed in Holocaust. some jewish women were also raped and all sorts of horrible things happened to their families..
And While I was seeing all these videos, pictures, and interviews, for sometime and somewhere in my heart I felt like killing all the Nazi Germans who led the holocaust.
Why would I have this feeling?? I am not a Jew.. My family or relatives were not killed by Nazi men, and finally I am a Ph.D graduate. Then WHY the feeling of killing those GERMANS arise in me?? This was an effect it had on me just during my one-day visit to the museum.
Imagine someone seeing such pictures and videos of brutal killing and murders day-in and day-out..What a profound effect it would have !!
And truly this is what is KASAB.
Let me ask you a question.. Why do u think we go to school/college/university?
To gain education , Right..
But why do we need this education, apart from getting a good job..
This is because we all have a craving.. Craving for knowledge, thats human instinct..
But when it comes to Religion people go to extreme and then the so called education, knowledge etc. goes into the drain, and we all or most of us go Insane..We forget to act wisely, think correctly and behave as Educated fools.. That is to say that Religion has the power to Brainwash the Educated..
I have seen interviews of some people living in Israel who are fanatical about their religion-ISLAM.. And Mind you they are none other than HARVARD university graduates (Harvard is one of the top class university in the whole world).. And there are such Educated Illiterates (as I address them) in every religion on Earth not just Islam...Islam was just an example.
Terrorism has nothing to do with Education or probably it has..But in the wrong direction !!!
Therefore, I do not agree with your argument that education is instrumental in preventing acts of 'TerrorISM' ..The root cause still is Religious ExtremISM !!!
Sheetal.Shirsat-Rohekar
Nicely written Dada..This kinda triggers the reader to actually think about what's happening around the world....
Very well put Ashish... This reminds me the interview of Advocate Ujwal Nikam after Kasab's Death... He mentioned the same thing... Destroying ISTs like Kasab will never solve the problem... There is a factory which generates so many Kasabs... I think eradication of ISM equals to eradication of that factory... Very nice article with totally different point of view...
Post a Comment